Challenge

3 rounds · 1 min 50 s

The conclusion under challenge

“We can end the Seorin MSA with an email notice.”

For Claude Opus 5.5Against Gemini 3.1 ProJudge GPT-6 Sol

  1. Round 1
    For: Clause 14.5 makes any notice effective once received. Seorin reads its email, a read receipt proves arrival, and Article 111 asks only for arrival.
    Against: Clause 14.2 names the methods, and 14.3 says email "shall not by itself constitute notice". A court reads the specific clause before the general one.
  2. Round 2
    For: Seorin accepted email for price changes twice this year without objecting, so the parties’ own practice supports email.
    Against: Amendment 2, section 3, excludes ending the agreement by name. Past price changes do not reach it.
  3. Round 3
    For: If challenged, the worst case is that the notice counts from a later date, not that it fails.
    Against: A later date could fall after October 31, and the agreement would renew for a year. The cost of being wrong is twelve months.

What held up

  • Broke: email alone. The Against side won rounds 2 and 3.
  • Held: actual receipt counts under clause 14.5, so the email copy is worth sending.
  • Changed: send registered mail by October 24, a week before the deadline, because a miss renews the agreement for a year.

Not settled: whether the price-change emails count as the parties’ practice. A person should decide that.